It can be good for helping with stopping oil from getting into your intake and intercooler.So is having both open breathers good or bad? Not sure if I'm following these posts.
Bad for emissions and crankcase ventilation.
The best way to rid of the PCV system would be to run a catch can with both valve covers feeding it from one side and the other side hooked downstream to your exhaust with a one way check valve for scavenging.