I would advise against the Mini. My ex's mom had one and it was a nightmare. It was a brand new (at the time) '08 turbo model with the manual and it kept blowing transmissions, interior was falling apart, rattles and creaks everywhere, the windows didn't seal right, etc.I hadn't given Mini's much thought until you said that. I have been reading reviews and they all seem to be glowing. Looks like I can get into a nicely appointed Mini S for right in the middle of my budget. I will test drive one soon. I just hope they are roomy for their size. It surprised me how much room I had in the GTI and R32; I'm not the biggest guy (6'1 190lbs) but the size scared me.
I actually looked at a Cobalt SS and did not like it. Performance wise it was just as you described, but the interior didn't sit well with me. Plus, navigation is not available.
09 wrx for 25k? downpipe and your in the 12's.
I agree with you completely. Still has the interior of a $14k XFE.
If you would prefer the body style of a sedan, you may look into the Jetta GLi. Basically a GTi but in a Jetta body. Handling, acceleration, engine, trans and all of that is the same just a different body. I'm thinking about picking one up as a DD actually.
If I were in that price range, I'd be going for a IS350. Man those cars turn my head every time I see them. I love the styling and they are pretty quick too.