Engine locked up at 4500 miles

Status
Not open for further replies.

slagburn

SVT Crazy Poster
Established Member
Joined
May 20, 2011
Messages
1,952
Location
Colorado
So with all your knowledge what do you think bent the rod ?? Better yet I'd like to know what the shop is saying caused it , I don't care if you are the dumbest mechanic out there you know rods just don't bend or break the way this happened and be considered the fault of the op , that's all were saying , what did the op do that caused that rod to bend and lock the engine up ?!!!??!? That's my question to you , and someone being honest and someone taking responsibility for a $4500 short block plus labor are 2 different things.

The cause of this problem has been posted multiple times in this thread. I'll give you a hint, you're right, rods don't just bend out of nowhere- something caused it.
 

Fun4me

New Member
Established Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2012
Messages
946
Location
chicago
If the OP wants a built block and the shop will "work" w/him w/o accepting responsibility, then maybe its a fair deal. If the OP pays full price for said build, then I find that problamatic. Just paying him to fix the engine, still leaves him a stock engine. But doing a build for him @ a $4500 discount w/o accepting official responsibilty is a differant story.
So I have to ask, which one is it?
 

CPRsm

Active Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2009
Messages
4,400
Location
San Diego, Ca
.... installation procedure as expected.
If the Op hasn't mentioned whether it was coolant or gas how can you possibly come to that conclusion?
The inj need to be tested either way by someone else other than the manufacturer. If the injectors do have a problem you don't want them in the new engine.
When the the plug was pull on the pan it would have told what locked the engine. If coolant, it settles at the bottom and they would have seen water drain first before the oil. If not coolant it was fuel. In this situation coolant is more likely. It takes a good bit of fluid to bend a rod. Coolant is more likel to fill a cyl while the car is off than fuel. Even a stuck injector will bleed line pressure after key off, and the key on. But not much fuel from a fuel pump prime UNLESS it primes to a target psi. Then you could have a probelm.
 

01bluesnake

Active Member
Established Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2009
Messages
3,431
Location
chicago burbs Des Plaines
If the OP wants a built block and the shop will "work" w/him w/o accepting responsibility, then maybe its a fair deal. If the OP pays full price for said build, then I find that problamatic. Just paying him to fix the engine, still leaves him a stock engine. But doing a build for him @ a $4500 discount w/o accepting official responsibilty is a differant story.
So I have to ask, which one is it?[/QUOTE

Would you see it a fair deal if you were in the op shoes? So because the op eventually wanted built block, the old shortblock and this event is not worth anything to him and he should just let it go?

If the Op hasn't mentioned whether it was coolant or gas how can you possibly come to that conclusion?
The inj need to be tested either way by someone else other than the manufacturer. If the injectors do have a problem you don't want them in the new engine.
When the the plug was pull on the pan it would have told what locked the engine. If coolant, it settles at the bottom and they would have seen water drain first before the oil. If not coolant it was fuel. In this situation coolant is more likely. It takes a good bit of fluid to bend a rod. Coolant is more likel to fill a cyl while the car is off than fuel. Even a stuck injector will bleed line pressure after key off, and the key on. But not much fuel from a fuel pump prime UNLESS it primes to a target psi. Then you could have a probelm.

Not sure if you are trying to say a headgasket was bad and leaked coolant into the cylinder, but that is a pretty fair stretch with the car having no smoking or misfire issues. If it was that severe, the cooling system would of been filled with combustion gases when the car was running and there would be coolant in the oil. Them installing the injectors, and allowing the fuel to fill the cylinder when removed from the rail is a more likely and believable cause. With high compression, very little fluid needs to be in the chamber to hydro lock the cylinder. Since they drove the car in and changed the injectors, the system was more than likely still under pressure and if they lifted the rail and one popped put. It would have no problem filling the cylinder.
 
Last edited:

01bluesnake

Active Member
Established Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2009
Messages
3,431
Location
chicago burbs Des Plaines
Trying to blame a bad head gasket although the car drove in and fine previous to the injector change is highly unlikely vs the event that let up to the hydrolock and bent rod.
 

KWClutch

Steve McQueen
Established Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2008
Messages
1,804
Location
Texas
1105684_o.gif
 

CPRsm

Active Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2009
Messages
4,400
Location
San Diego, Ca
I've seen more bent rods from coolant. It has to be a good leak to misfire or smoke. I've seen them leak and pass a hydro carbon test. But blows the rad cap under WOT. The last one that did it at my shop showed no signs what so ever. One before that, the only reason I knew was I popped his radiator after 10 seconds of running and the cooling system was pressurized. Passed hydro carbon test as well. Leak into his engine. That cyl looked brand new. Plenty plausible. More u likely is a rail leaking into a cyl on an injector change. I that was the case it would have locked first crank after install. Not multiple starts. It's all pretty far fetched but something locked it up. Thing w a bad injector is it would have to be keyed up multiple times before a start to get enough fuel into the cyl to hurt something.
 

01bluesnake

Active Member
Established Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2009
Messages
3,431
Location
chicago burbs Des Plaines
I'll have to go back and reread, but could of sworn op said they pulled it on the dyno, shut it down, changed the injectors and locked up on the attempted restart, not multiple starts.

I've also had all kinds of head gasket concerns, but there was always something else to go with the HG concern. Either blowing radiator, blowing out of or cracking reservoir, loss of coolant, misfire, smoke. They also haven't just happened over a hour time span with no other issues and enough coolant loss to hydro lock a motor. There would of been misfire problems upon start ups, with smoke and hard cranking.

For the shop having no issues starting the car and being a hot restart, then pulling it on the dyno and then locks up, just doesn't add up
 
Last edited:

CPRsm

Active Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2009
Messages
4,400
Location
San Diego, Ca
A hot restart would lead me more to coolant. 16 psi trying to push coolant into a cyl after key off.
Most all the cars I've worked on over the last 15 years have been classics. Not driven much the coolant consumption is hard to see. Idk, I just don't think because it was in there possession last makes them responsible without proof.
 

01bluesnake

Active Member
Established Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2009
Messages
3,431
Location
chicago burbs Des Plaines
I don't know. I've said what is the most likely cause of the failure, within the time frame, and work that was performed. If people choose to believe otherwise, then be it. I know its hard to prove without proof, but with all the info and facts of the situation, its very hard to prove something else caused a bent rod. I'll leave it at that, and hoping for the best to the op. I'm out of this thread.

It was fine on the hot restart when he brought the car, then it was moved to the dyno and next start after injector change it locked up.
 
Last edited:

me32

BEASTLY SHELBY GT500 TVS
Moderator
Premium Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2005
Messages
18,482
Location
CA,NorCal
Hey foofkiller I'm still waiting for that proof that its a known issue fords having problems with there stock rods.
 

FoofKiller

I> /\/\
Established Member
Joined
Jun 13, 2007
Messages
3,858
Location
state of confusion
I already figured the shop would try to wiggle out of the problem as I noted earlier. I've worked as a tech for 15 years combined at Ford as a master tech and run a performance shop. Anytime anything happened if it was my fault, I always accepted blame and responsibility and paid for any problems encountered. Just seeing this and the shop placing blame on everything other than them self is just sad and BS. Being honest would of made this shop look very good, but anyone with mechanical automotive knowledge knows the shop is clearly at fault and they are thieves for trying to make someone else pay for their damage.

The shop has not tried to BS their way out of anything. You're jumping to conclusions here and your comment is on the verge of slanderous.


LMAO! Bastard. :lol:
 

Spd2Stang

I just WOT in my pants
Established Member
Joined
May 16, 2011
Messages
833
Location
Keller, TX
Hey foofkiller I'm still waiting for that proof that its a known issue fords having problems with there stock rods.

Ive only found 2 threads on different forums regarding a seized motor issue that people have posted. Both were stock and locked up while driving.

Early on in this thread it was stated a local ford dealer to the shop said they had experienced a handful of cars in with that issue.

taken from the two threads i found:
Update on my Engine. The service supervisor told me that they shipped my engine back to Ford because it is a "reoccurring issue" they wish to investigate in the coyote engine.
got my Mustang back today. They wouldn't tell me what happened to it, and I couldn't locate the tech who operated on her, but service sheet says "there was excessive scaring on the cams due to lack of lubrication. Removed drain plug, removed only 3 qts of oil. Removed spark plugs no sign of excessive oil consumption.
 

87hatchy

Member
Established Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2009
Messages
771
Location
Earth
There is some SERIOUS, HARDCORE nutswinging going on in this thread trying to say its not the shops fault. Geezus. Do you people work there or something? I didn't read the whole thread because I don't have time to rummage through all the BS.

Here's what I am gathering after reading the first page...

1. The car was fine

2. Cams get installed -> Car breaks


How is this not the shops fault????????????
 

me32

BEASTLY SHELBY GT500 TVS
Moderator
Premium Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2005
Messages
18,482
Location
CA,NorCal
Ive only found 2 threads on different forums regarding a seized motor issue that people have posted. Both were stock and locked up while driving.

Early on in this thread it was stated a local ford dealer to the shop said they had experienced a handful of cars in with that issue.

taken from the two threads i found:

Thanks for the info..I still find it hard that this is a ford issue as this is the 1st I've heard of it.
 

FoofKiller

I> /\/\
Established Member
Joined
Jun 13, 2007
Messages
3,858
Location
state of confusion
There is some SERIOUS, HARDCORE nutswinging going on in this thread trying to say its not the shops fault. Geezus. Do you people work there or something? I didn't read the whole thread because I don't have time to rummage through all the BS.

Here's what I am gathering after reading the first page...

1. The car was fine

2. Cams get installed -> Car breaks


How is this not the shops fault????????????

You need to re-read the thread. That is not what happened. Try coming up with some adult venacular of your own rather than the usual internet jargon of that a teenager on Facebook. Swing on that.
 

Spoolx

Active Member
Established Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2010
Messages
1,780
Location
Florida
Its obviously the shops fault, its just not worth it to the OP to pursue it. Its his money and if he wants to waste it let him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread



Top