But just FYI, my insurance for my family just went up $400 a year, and we have no accidents and no tickets...
The insurance companies are full of crap lately IMO.
Wow, now that sucks! I have USAA and my rates keep going down. Which is why I love USAA.
OP, definitely get a couple of repair quotes and then make the decision. I have a feeling, though, that the total is going to be high enough where you'll have to file a claim. And then you'll have to how much your insurance increases.