Guy barely bumped into me so I got his info and said I'd have it buffed out and send him the bill, didn't look like much damage at all. I looked closer at it a few minutes later once I got to work. Not only is it scratched through the paint, there are two deep marks at the point where the paint stops and the black starts made by his license plate bolts. There is also a light crease just above and between the marks from the top of his plate bracket, and now the gap below the tail lights and trunk is over a half an inch. I can also see the gap on the side where the rear qtr meets the bumper cover. I've contacted both our insurers and he has taken responsibility so there are no problems there. I'm just surprised how much damage there is from such a light bump, so much for 5 mph bumpers. I'm going to insist the cover needs replaced because of the two dents and the crease. Just curious, any one have a similar repair and have had an estimate for a replacement and repaint of the rear bumper cover?