Observation? Is it just me or does the left rear fender well look like it has red overspray in it? I don't remember any of my low mile cars looking like that, also in the 2 wheel pictures the brake rotors look groved. Maybe I'm seeing things.
That's why it would be cool to know where this car has been. It would explain the imperfections you guys are noticing. This car probably wasn't intended to be kept this long with such low miles. Maybe it didn't sell and sat outside for a while. It could have been neglected. Its not like a 93 Cobra where someone might buy it to keep in 'museum brand new' condition because they anticipate it being collectible down the road. I don't think people were thinking in 1993 that 5.0 notches were going to be collector pieces in 2006.
Its in a climate controlled area NOW. But where was it in 1993 or 1994 or 1995? That may answer some of the questions of body damage and un-original tires.