Yeah its all about the SEC oh wait where was all the outrage when they put Michigan and OSU in last year - - - JPRO why didn't you want to storm any bowls in protest then???
Official 2023 College Football Season thread
- Thread starter rborden
- Start date
I'm going MICH, WASH, FSU.
TX or BAMA for the last spot is a tough one. Ask yourself which was more impressive: TX beating BAMA or BAMA beating Whoregia? I say BAMA's win. And which was a worse loss: TX losing to OK or BAMA losing to TX? I say TX losing to OK was worse.
Therefore: I say BAMA gets the fourth slot.
TX or BAMA for the last spot is a tough one. Ask yourself which was more impressive: TX beating BAMA or BAMA beating Whoregia? I say BAMA's win. And which was a worse loss: TX losing to OK or BAMA losing to TX? I say TX losing to OK was worse.
Therefore: I say BAMA gets the fourth slot.
I hope the female is just a guest.
My guess is both Texas and FSU get the shaft in favor of the expected two spot SEC love fest. Using the logic of Alabama for the spot, both Texas and Ohio State also deserve the last spot.
As a Bama fan I believe Bama could beat a few of them teams today. But it doesn’t work that way. M,W, F, T should be in.
TEXAS vs OK is a rivalry game that many outside of Texas/Oklahoma simply do not comprehend. AFAIK its the only CFB game played on neutral ground. I don’t care if OU wins any other games in the season as long as they beat UT. I imagine many UT fans feel the same damn way. UT deserves to be in CFB playiff, their one loss to Oklahoma was in game where all f’n bets are off. The fact remains UT beat Bama and won the Big12 conference to boot. They should get the nod with that win over Bama. That Bama squad played a helluva of game against Georgia, too bad that exact same squad (personnel wise) didn’t show up against UT.
I don’t think any of us are a big fan of the current CFB format.. wish there was a wild card game.. I would love to see UT and Bama play again and see who wants it the most.
Last edited:
I'm looking at the selection scenario from a total picture view. At the time TX lost to OK we only had a partial picture of how good each team was since the season was still young. Now we have a full picture and OK has lost twice and is ranked #12 and BAMA bumped off Georgia who hadn't lost in like 29 games. TX beat OK St. who was so-so this year. TX is ranked 7 and BAMA 8. BAMA's victory yesterday will propel them past TX in the rankings I believe.
I see your point, but I doubt it. Just because Bama may have not played to their potential against UT, doesn’t mean they should leap frog UT into the CFB playoffs.. They are the same exact team personnel wise that played UT. Truth be told Bama has looked pretty shakey this season even though they won out and played a helluva game against Georgia..too bad Georgia didn’t step on the gas till it was too late.
With all due respect, and remember I'm sayin' with all due respect, that logic ain't worth a velvet painting of a whale and a dolphin gettin' it on.
Uh-oh. TX fan in the house!
I protested big 10 team that got in without a big10 championship...thats a automatic disqualifier in my book...thats twice a team that didnt win thier conference got in and it pissed me off both times
Just saw a opportunity to stir the pot so i thought i would take it lol.
Luckily this is the last year of the four team playoff because no matter who they pick there are gonna be a couple of really good teams left out. You could throw a dart at any of the one loss power five teams and make a case for them getting into the playoff.
Don't be a Bammer. Texas beat Bama by 10 in Tuscaloosa. Both are 1 loss conference champs and both are 3-1 vs. top 25 teams. Again, on the field, at Bama, Texas was a double digit winner and the game wasn't even that close. Playing the games count.
Last year there was no head to head to compare OSU to the #5 team. This year, Texas literally beat Bama by double digits in their house. Like it or not, Texas proved to be better.
Right. If you ask Vegas right now, they will tell you that its UGA/Bama/Michigan/OSU vs. the field, yet 3 of those teams aren't getting in. If you had to lay money on any of these 4 vs. Washington, FSU, etc. you would take the Dogs/Tide/Skunks/Bucks. The only team that is an outlier is Texas. Their roster is loaded and they have looked great the last few weeks, plus they beat Bama on the road by 10. Maybe Texas is the best team.
Make sure ya'll reach out to your GA friends and make sure they're ok. I aint seen anyone fall that hard since Lucifer.
Are you trying to outTAF TAF? Cause you sound just as insane as him.
Users who are viewing this thread
