it depends on how you calculate it. I could sell this place today, buy a smaller place and bank close to 200k. I could bank more than that if I wanted to move to land I own in MO. I would agree that technically I wouldn't see a ROI unless I sold. but whateverYou only have a return on investment if you have $120k in your pocket right now or if you have that after moving to a comparable house. The only investment you're getting a return on is a place to retire