Boss owners who've bought s550 gtpp's have put this to test, and rest. I'm not going to spend my time digging up all the posts from various sites, but google searching will lead to many of them.
I agree that comparing lap times from different days with different drivers is a refutable metric. Scientific method would be to limit variables. Also, just reading weather conditions of a given day doesn't go far enough. It may have rained heavy the day(s) prior to a test day with clear or possibly better conditions than a day being compared to.
Basically, unless it's same day, same driver, the findings aren't really absolute, just basically informative of how that car runs in xyz conditions.
From drives I've been on as a passenger, the s550 is quick, but not as stiff and direct as a boss(ls). That said, it may honestly be quicker, they just drive/feel very different, but both are fast. There is more compliance and comfort in the s550 even with a track package.
Having driven a boss and s550, I can easily say the s550 gtpp is potentially faster than a boss 302. I haven't personally driven an ls so I can't comment, but it's spitting distance close from experiences I've had.
Consider this, if you allow different drivers to conduct a test of lap times, one may be great at toe heel downshifting, and the other may be nervous or unwilling to do so, or just not efficient at it. That alone is 2-3 seconds a lap. Do both drivers have the same credentials and skill level? There are too many variable to go about lap times like that. The document would have 75 asterisks explained at the end of the data
*when Bill was on point
* when joe wasn't sick
* when Bill wasn't hungry
* when joe has on good shoes
* when Bill was excited
*when joe was tired
... No thanks.
I agree that comparing lap times from different days with different drivers is a refutable metric. Scientific method would be to limit variables. Also, just reading weather conditions of a given day doesn't go far enough. It may have rained heavy the day(s) prior to a test day with clear or possibly better conditions than a day being compared to.
Basically, unless it's same day, same driver, the findings aren't really absolute, just basically informative of how that car runs in xyz conditions.
From drives I've been on as a passenger, the s550 is quick, but not as stiff and direct as a boss(ls). That said, it may honestly be quicker, they just drive/feel very different, but both are fast. There is more compliance and comfort in the s550 even with a track package.
Having driven a boss and s550, I can easily say the s550 gtpp is potentially faster than a boss 302. I haven't personally driven an ls so I can't comment, but it's spitting distance close from experiences I've had.
Consider this, if you allow different drivers to conduct a test of lap times, one may be great at toe heel downshifting, and the other may be nervous or unwilling to do so, or just not efficient at it. That alone is 2-3 seconds a lap. Do both drivers have the same credentials and skill level? There are too many variable to go about lap times like that. The document would have 75 asterisks explained at the end of the data
*when Bill was on point
* when joe wasn't sick
* when Bill wasn't hungry
* when joe has on good shoes
* when Bill was excited
*when joe was tired
... No thanks.