The problem is I've been seeing this on bone stock cars on the factory tunes.
Since Winter blended fuel ended, I (and other tuners) have been seeing high knock values from 91-93 octane all up and down the East coast and Mid West. This was not the case 1 year ago. I can't help but think there has been a regional blend change causing the issues, or perhaps a huge volume of sub-par fuel?
The only thing similar out here we've found is Chevron 91 tends to take 2-3 degrees less timing than 76/BP/Shell. 76 being our 'preferred' fuel.
I've seen logs from places where only 90 octane is available and no knock logged, at the same time as I'm receiving logs with Knock on 5.0's with 93 in the tank. There is far more to the anti-detonation properties of fuel than *just* octane. Octane (in general) is a good indication of a good anti-knock fuel, but it does not mean as much as people think.
The only other thing we can think of is 'false' knock from either Loose, or faulty knock sensors, but we've not had a car in Northern CA with any logged knock problem (that has not been resolved with better fuel) to test this theory.
Do you make these tunes for 91 since you are out in CA or do you take geographical location into consideration when writing a tune? Myself and the pervious owner have been using 93 since the car was born. Do you prefer us east coast guys to run 89 over 93?