I wheeled these out, hit them with a hose, dried dried them off and took some shots with my Droid. Approximately 600 miles on each. No burnouts, plugs, or patches. Wheels have no scratches on the faces and were never curbed, etc. One wheel has about 1/4" where the wheel looks to have oxidized near its center.
This is a set of four factory wheels, each shod with a factory rear 285 Goodyear. I sold the front 255's and ran 285's on all four corners. No rub at stock ride height. Complete with factory TPMS sensors.
Left to right...
Second wheel from left did indeed have something get under the clearcoat, about 1/4" long or so. It honestly did that while sitting there. When these were put away they had no flaws on their faces. It is the only one.